Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Align Engineering

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Align Engineering

    I purchased some Align spares for a 700 DFC head and noticed, what I would consider, extremely dodgy engineering.








    When those M3x6 bolts are inserted through the blade grip arms, I measured 2.5mm of thread protruding through the mating surface, which would be an effective thread length of about 2.2mm. Does anyone have one they can measure, as this seems way too little?

    I did some calculations, and unless I'm mistaken, for a 10.6 steel bolt threaded into 6061 aluminium, the length of thread engagement, in a normal situation, should be around 4.5mm, and with the stresses and vibrations these joints are subjected to, I wouldn't use less than 2x the nominal diameter of the bolt, which would be 6mm in this case... but 2.5mm is way too short.
    Last edited by Gixxer; 23-11-2013, 02:51 AM.

  • #2
    if they were longer would they not foul the outer case of the blade grip bearing? not saying that is an excuse for poor engineering but it may be a reason?
    Raptor G4 Nitro, TT Redline 100 + Redline Pipe, BLS 255HV's Cyclic, BLS256HV Tail, VX1.
    Raptor 50 Nitro, CSM HL200, NES591's all round! Stock woodies! TT50 engine. Dead Had a nasty accident with some stairs...
    T-Rex 450 SE v2 GY401/S9650 with S9257 gear mod Tail, HS65HB's Cyclic stock ESC and Motor. Dead Had an amusing fight with the ground....
    T-Rex 450 Pro DFC, MKS DS92A+ cyclic, Align DS520 Tail, (3GX V3) Dead... I'm getting really good at crashing...
    Blade MCPx wall banger with dx4e tx
    Haiyin 2200mAh 20-30C lipos for both 450's
    Phoenix Sim
    JR X2610 & JR XG8



    Comment


    • #3
      I've replaced the 6mm bolts with 8mm bolts and had no problems with them bottoming out. I've not tried anything longer.

      Comment


      • #4
        While it might not seem right I've seen no problem with these bolts snapping Even in some pretty hard smashes that bent the top hub etc. Isn't there another locating pin on the blade grip?
        TREX 700E DFC SK540

        TREX 550E AR7200BX

        Logo 400SE SK540

        Check Out My Youtube Channel http://www.youtube.com/user/pocoyo2212?feature=mhee

        Comment


        • #5
          Doesn't the arm go into a slot?
          To help take the load.

          It's almost 1 diameter.
          Cheers Paul

          sigpic
          Citizen #42

          Comment


          • #6
            The arm does fit into a slot but the linkage is connected about 20mm out from that.

            It's the stripping force of the internal thread I'd be worried about.

            Comment


            • #7
              2.2mm sounds too short. I don't have the engineer math to work it out but note than many brand heli frame bolts are 6mm through 2mm frame under a washer..so again about 3mm of thread into spaces/bearing holders etc. Yes, do realise not the ame forces/vibes there. Does threadlock affect the calcs and that there are twin bolts? Has anyone heard of a failure here?
              PGK
              450Pro Clone fb, Trex500 fbl beastx, Trex 600N fbl beastx, Trex700N fbl msh brain, Spectra G Hanson 26 3dmax fb, Blitz Avro fb...Futaba 8FG

              Comment


              • #8
                Yes the stock bolts are way to short and as a result with prolonged use of these bolts we have seen many failures in flight resulting in the heli tearing itself apart!!! I have replaced mine with 8mm bolts they do not hit the radial bearings and will give a great peace of mind from these shearing!!! I highly recommend everyone to change these bolts!!!

                Click to visit RC Hero or visit
                www.rcheroflightteam.co.uk for the flight team blog.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I have seen 2 failures at charmouth

                  Click to visit RC Hero or visit
                  www.rcheroflightteam.co.uk for the flight team blog.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Bolt change today then.
                    PGK
                    450Pro Clone fb, Trex500 fbl beastx, Trex 600N fbl beastx, Trex700N fbl msh brain, Spectra G Hanson 26 3dmax fb, Blitz Avro fb...Futaba 8FG

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by pgkevet View Post
                      Bolt change today then.
                      Jus make sure the bolts you decide on using don't foul on the radial bearing then all should be fine

                      Click to visit RC Hero or visit
                      www.rcheroflightteam.co.uk for the flight team blog.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Chris Boughton View Post
                        I have seen 2 failures at charmouth
                        I saw helis crash first then bolts shear.
                        And that must of been all the crashes at this last Charmouth.

                        If 8mm fit why the hell didn't Align do it.
                        Nightmare
                        Cheers Paul

                        sigpic
                        Citizen #42

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Geek View Post
                          I saw helis crash first then bolts shear.
                          And that must of been all the crashes at this last Charmouth.

                          If 8mm fit why the hell didn't Align do it.
                          Nightmare
                          There was connor sloan at the last charmouth took of he rolled the heli and it jus self distruct and then there was alex hawtin at spring charmouth the video says it all!! I guess align jus didn't pay enough attention to this!!
                          Last edited by Chris Boughton; 23-11-2013, 08:35 AM.

                          Click to visit RC Hero or visit
                          www.rcheroflightteam.co.uk for the flight team blog.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Geek View Post
                            I saw helis crash first then bolts shear.
                            And that must of been all the crashes at this last Charmouth.

                            If 8mm fit why the hell didn't Align do it.
                            Nightmare
                            "Here big bag six bol'."
                            "Six bol' too shor'. Nee' ate or bwake."
                            "Ah, so betta - sell mo' spair!"
                            PGK
                            450Pro Clone fb, Trex500 fbl beastx, Trex 600N fbl beastx, Trex700N fbl msh brain, Spectra G Hanson 26 3dmax fb, Blitz Avro fb...Futaba 8FG

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Chris Boughton View Post
                              There was connor sloan at the last charmouth took of he rolled the heli and it jus self distruct and then there was alex hawtin at spring charmouth the video says it all!! I guess align jus didn't pay enough attention to this!!
                              I find it difficult to analyse a crash from some of these vids. Clearly the tail box comes off..whether boom struck or not. A couple of frames earlier the boom stays appear to flex but whether that is a dual strike or first signs of the tail box failing is arguable. I don't see this as primarily the grips whch you could expect to fail secondarily to any of the above.
                              PGK
                              450Pro Clone fb, Trex500 fbl beastx, Trex 600N fbl beastx, Trex700N fbl msh brain, Spectra G Hanson 26 3dmax fb, Blitz Avro fb...Futaba 8FG

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X