Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Lucky escape

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Lucky escape

    Had a great days flying today, however on the last flight of the evening I noticed that the tail was waggling as if the gyro gain was too high mainly at the 12 o’clock of a loop while trying to keep it inverted NO H/H then I thought I will try it with H/H but it was no better.
    The tail also waggled badly on a roll!
    Have any of you guys had a similar problem?
    I landed the heli to check it out why the tail is waggling; this is what I found.








    The paddles have jammed themselves in front of each of the leading edges of the blades.







    Can you please tell me what could have caused this ?

    How is it possible for the heli to fly this the way it is!


    I have checked the gears, all seem to be okay no missing teeth or anything like that.

    Thanks in advance.

    Z
    Keep Well
    Zaidy



    T Rex 700 LE FBL Spectrum 7200 Beast X
    T Rex 700 FB
    T Rex 600 NSP FBL
    Spectrum 7200 Beast X
    DJI Quad, NAZA M V1
    DJI Hexa, NAZA M V2

    Rhyl and District Model Flying Club
    http://rdmfc.forumotion.co.uk

  • #2
    wow thats impressive, especially as you got it down in one piece very interested in how it happened too

    Comment


    • #3
      Thats very strange cos flybar is bent to direction of rotation which I would say is impossible in flight.
      Today's outlook is fine for flying.
      • Spektrum DX18 gen2, Phoenix Sims, Align MR25XP.
      • Blade Nano, mCP X, 130x, Blade 180, Mini T 450se
      • Trex 250dfc Gpro, Trex 500EFL Gpro.
      • Trex 600E Gpro DFC, Trex 600NSP now Gpro, DFC, Redline 56
      • Flickr Through My Pictures.
      • A helicopter is an aircraft that is lifted and propelled by one or more horizontal rotors because Wikipedia said so.

      Comment


      • #4
        Never seen anything like that before, must be a iffy flybar or a vibration issue, does the flybar bend easy?
        James

        Sponsored by
        Align-Trex.co.uk
        Optifuel/optipower
        MKS servotech


        5 Eddie gold stars and christmas star

        Comment


        • #5
          I can't see how that could possibly happen in flight.
          The flybar is bent with the rotation of the head, i.e. forwards, not backwards - so the paddles are up against the trailing edge of the blades, not the leading edge as suggested.

          There is no way that I'm aware of that a metal bar can bend itself forwards in advance of the natural rotational force it is encountering?

          Is it April 1st again??
          Cheers,
          Rob
          Team Align, Midland Helicopters, Optifuel, Cyclone Blades, Scorpion Motors, Thunder Power, Savox Servos, JR Propo

          | 3D Championship

          Comment


          • #6
            Dodgy batch of steel,im in the roadsweeper brush bussiness and get soft batches

            Fairplay for getting it down
            T- rex 600n V-bar
            Logo 550sx V-bar
            Logo 600sx V-bar
            Logo 600sx V-bar night flyer

            VBControl, but not the gay white version as i'm simply not gay enough to pull it off!

            Comment


            • #7
              If it was weak steel, it would have bent backwards not forwards.
              The force being applied to the paddles/flybar would be against the rotorhead rotation, not with it, or indeed taking precendence over it, as is shown in the pics?

              Cheers,
              Rob
              Team Align, Midland Helicopters, Optifuel, Cyclone Blades, Scorpion Motors, Thunder Power, Savox Servos, JR Propo

              | 3D Championship

              Comment


              • #8
                Been sat for the best part of 20 minutes working this one out & I'm stumped!!
                The laws of physics wouldn't allow this to happen due to the forces involved and the direction of rotation.
                Or so you would think
                Cheers,


                Gazza


                We do not stop playing because we grow old...We grow old because we stop playing.


                Stainburn Heli club

                Trex600LE
                Radix blades
                Align DS610's on Cyclic
                Align DS650 on Tail, Futaba GY520 Gyro
                O.S 55 Powerplant O.S Powerboost muffler
                Spectrum DX7

                sigpic



                www.aurorra.co.uk

                www.fast-lad.co.uk

                And a very proud owner of X3 Eddie Gold Stars

                Comment


                • #9
                  It's as if the rotorhead came to a sudden stop and the inertia of the flybar paddles was so great that they continued to travel, bending the flybar.
                  Kasama, Minicopter, Henseleit, JR, Shape, Beam
                  Robbe, RMJ Raptor gasser, powered by
                  Spartan, Spirit, BeastX, Kontronik, CY Total-G, DX8

                  member of Epsom Downs and Bloobird clubs
                  Proud recipient of 7 EGS! and a platinum star

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by moonmanflyer View Post
                    Never seen anything like that before, must be a iffy flybar or a vibration issue, does the flybar bend easy?

                    no it does not, in fact I am having a hard time bending it back in order to pull it out ! next is to cut it.

                    Originally posted by robgt View Post
                    I can't see how that could possibly happen in flight.
                    The flybar is bent with the rotation of the head, i.e. forwards, not backwards - so the paddles are up against the trailing edge of the blades, not the leading edge as suggested.

                    There is no way that I'm aware of that a metal bar can bend itself forwards in advance of the natural rotational force it is encountering?

                    Rob
                    What you don't see in the picture is the way the paddles were once I landed, they were jammed in front of the Leading edge, the are white scuff marks there.


                    Some of the Suggestions so far, similar to Trillian
                    "sloppy blades" but they are just tight
                    "The engine stopped dead/the main shaft stopped dead. But the blades carried on and clocked the flybar and paddles"

                    I can carry out the repair but what if it happens again ! will I be so lucky ? am I doing something I shouldn't be ? (apart from flying instead of working)
                    Some of you guys throw your helis around with out any problems, all I do is basic stuff.

                    Please keep them coming guys.

                    Regards

                    Z
                    Last edited by HAWK 30; 10-06-2009, 08:07 AM. Reason: Trying to answer everybody in one post !
                    Keep Well
                    Zaidy



                    T Rex 700 LE FBL Spectrum 7200 Beast X
                    T Rex 700 FB
                    T Rex 600 NSP FBL
                    Spectrum 7200 Beast X
                    DJI Quad, NAZA M V1
                    DJI Hexa, NAZA M V2

                    Rhyl and District Model Flying Club
                    http://rdmfc.forumotion.co.uk

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Stumped aswell :S

                      Try flying it again? this time record it?

                      ^^ Dont actually do it.
                      "Anger and Frustration bring the best out of my flying ability.. because generally I don't give a shit either if the machine hit's the deck or stay's in the air - both will accomplish satisfaction, but most of all it exerts the feeling of flying conservatively. - Callum"

                      www.callumheli.co.uk

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by robgt View Post
                        I can't see how that could possibly happen in flight.
                        The flybar is bent with the rotation of the head, i.e. forwards, not backwards - so the paddles are up against the trailing edge of the blades, not the leading edge as suggested.

                        There is no way that I'm aware of that a metal bar can bend itself forwards in advance of the natural rotational force it is encountering?

                        Is it April 1st again??
                        Cheers,
                        Rob
                        Exactly!
                        Today's outlook is fine for flying.
                        • Spektrum DX18 gen2, Phoenix Sims, Align MR25XP.
                        • Blade Nano, mCP X, 130x, Blade 180, Mini T 450se
                        • Trex 250dfc Gpro, Trex 500EFL Gpro.
                        • Trex 600E Gpro DFC, Trex 600NSP now Gpro, DFC, Redline 56
                        • Flickr Through My Pictures.
                        • A helicopter is an aircraft that is lifted and propelled by one or more horizontal rotors because Wikipedia said so.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by trillian View Post
                          It's as if the rotorhead came to a sudden stop and the inertia of the flybar paddles was so great that they continued to travel, bending the flybar.
                          Not without seeing some sort of damage to paddles or blades!!!
                          Today's outlook is fine for flying.
                          • Spektrum DX18 gen2, Phoenix Sims, Align MR25XP.
                          • Blade Nano, mCP X, 130x, Blade 180, Mini T 450se
                          • Trex 250dfc Gpro, Trex 500EFL Gpro.
                          • Trex 600E Gpro DFC, Trex 600NSP now Gpro, DFC, Redline 56
                          • Flickr Through My Pictures.
                          • A helicopter is an aircraft that is lifted and propelled by one or more horizontal rotors because Wikipedia said so.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Hawk, have you upset the missus recently, could be some spousal sabotage...
                            sigpicX2

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by tourerjim View Post
                              Not without seeing some sort of damage to paddles or blades!!!

                              The leading edge has white scuff marking on both blades and one of the trailing edges has a small impact damage as it folded against the blade holder !
                              White Marking



                              Impact damage


                              Where Impact damage occurred
                              Keep Well
                              Zaidy



                              T Rex 700 LE FBL Spectrum 7200 Beast X
                              T Rex 700 FB
                              T Rex 600 NSP FBL
                              Spectrum 7200 Beast X
                              DJI Quad, NAZA M V1
                              DJI Hexa, NAZA M V2

                              Rhyl and District Model Flying Club
                              http://rdmfc.forumotion.co.uk

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X