Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

FBL System for beginner opinion Bailout or not?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • FBL System for beginner opinion Bailout or not?

    Hi Guys,
    A long story short but persuaded my friend at work to buy a 450 pro heli and he picked up one from Midland hes only flown 250 size quads before.

    He's now in need of and asking me about FBL systems and specifically bailout function. Not having used bailout as I only fly Spartan im not in a position to advise so I thought id throw this one open to opinions on here.

    Not wanting to start a FBL war btw!

    Do you guys think its advisable to get a FBL controller with bailout or not? and if so which one would be the recommendation bearing in mind ideally it would need to be not massively expensive and ideally second hand (as he's not got that much money to throw at it currently)

    opinions greatly appreciated!

    Thanks

    Rich
    Heli's: Align 700X, TSA Infusion 700e Platinum, Align 600e Dominator, Align 600n pro DFC, Align 450 Pro DFC Stretched
    Fixed Wing: SEBART Suhkoi 50e
    Gear: Futaba 14SG

    Newton Abbot Heli Club: http://www.naheliclub.org.uk/

    Zeal Blades UK Flight Team www.zealblades.com

  • #2
    Why not just get a spartan for it, its tiny so will be perfect for a 450, it's a good unit, easy to set up and tune. Plus you use Spartan so you can easily help out, set up and tuning etc. I once had a Beast x on a 450 and it worked well.

    As for bail out, I have never used it and doubt if I ever will but everyone seems to want it now? What did we do before rescue became available?...... we had balls
    Goblin black nitro, Trex 700N, Vbar control 👍🏻

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by Flat Eric View Post
      What did we do before rescue became available?...... we had balls
      Thanks for the input mate.
      Yes, to a degree I agree and suggested a Spartan for all the reasons you said BUT I do remember when I was learning, bailout/recovery would have saved me a shit-load of money in spare parts..lol.

      Im not sure if I was in a position just starting out that id ignore bailout equipped FBL just because of big kahunas

      Rich
      Heli's: Align 700X, TSA Infusion 700e Platinum, Align 600e Dominator, Align 600n pro DFC, Align 450 Pro DFC Stretched
      Fixed Wing: SEBART Suhkoi 50e
      Gear: Futaba 14SG

      Newton Abbot Heli Club: http://www.naheliclub.org.uk/

      Zeal Blades UK Flight Team www.zealblades.com

      Comment


      • #4
        I have only used the ikon / msh brain.

        But have found my flying has improved a lot since switching.
        I hardly ever use the bailout out.

        But it's good to know it's there and it works if needed.

        When I first got it.
        I had to teach myself not to rely upon it.

        Has you tend to activate it at the slightest thing.
        But now I activate it about once in 10 or more flights.

        Depends what I'm trying to learn.
        Heli's: Trex 700 - os gt15hz : Goblin 380 & MSH Brain - Trex 450 Ikon : Blade 550x & 180cfx
        FPV: Sky Cruise 2400 - Cyclops Tornado - 700tvl cam
        SkyWalker - Cyclops Tornado - 700tvl cam
        DJI F550 - Naza v2 - iOsd - BT module - 700tvl cam
        Mini Talon - MFD - 700tvl cam

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Rich_H View Post
          Im not sure if I was in a position just starting out that id ignore bailout equipped FBL just because of big kahunas

          Rich
          That is just my opinion but I suppose nearly all fbl units have bailout now and they are quite cheap second hand
          Goblin black nitro, Trex 700N, Vbar control 👍🏻

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Flat Eric View Post
            What did we do before rescue became available?...... we had balls
            Crashed more often maybe?

            BeastX rescue is very good, but needs to be a Microbeast Plus or Spektrum AR7210BX to have the rescue functionality. Either can be upgraded to rescue firmware if bought used and not previously upgraded. But note that the older units i.e. Microbeast and AR7200BX cannot be upgraded to rescue as they don't have the 6-axis sensor. For a beginner there is also a self-levelling trainer mode, although I only use mine for last resort rescue. BeastX is a pretty beginner friendly FBL unit too and the one I started with and still use.

            Other options are Spirit and MSH Brain/iKon. There should be plenty of the latter on the used market with the recent introduction of Brain 2. The older Brain units can be updated to rescue for free and rescue is standard on all Spirit FBLs.
            SAB Goblin 380 KSE - latest love thang
            Lynx OXY 3 - my mini flagship!
            Blade 180 CFX - field beater for new moves
            Blade Red Bull BO-105 CB 130 X - scale fun flying at the field when the tail isn't broken, which is not often.
            Blade mCPX - sold

            Blade Nano QX - house fly of choice
            Blade mCX2 - retired but will be back when the kids get a bit bigger

            Spektrum DX8 - for everything
            ne
            Xt sim - the sim I started out with
            Heli-X sim - my new favourite sim!

            Comment


            • #7
              I'm out of the loop, but I would recommend spirit. Not the best FBL out there, but I've found it to be very agile and precise on my 700 and the bailout is very handy to have. They're currently about £125 with the £ dropping like a stone.
              Harry

              Mikado Logo 700 | VBar Neo | JR HV Servos | Pyro 750-50L | Kontronik Kosmik 160HV + buffer pack|
              Thunder Tiger G4 E720 | CGY760 FBL | BLS272SV + BLS276SV | Align 800MX Dom 440kv | Kontronik PowerJive 120HV + Opti UltraGuard |
              SAB Kraken 580 6S | Spirit FBL | BLS173SV + BLS276SV | HK4025 1100kV | Kontronik Kolibri 140LV + Opti UltraGuard |


              And a pillow for the doghouse...

              Powered by Futaba 18SZ

              Comment


              • #8
                I have 4 heli's on beastx & 3 on spirit , both units work well , you still have to train yourself to use bailout but it's a great thing to have & should only help with progress
                , I've only recently put the 3 spirit units on , I think it would have been better if I flew with them from the start as I have hit the TH & Bailout at the same time lol , I'm glad I put them on & has saved a few crashes so paid for them selfs , also lets me try new thing knowing I can recover if I need to
                I wouldn't discount the beastx as it's a good easy to use unit & cheap
                Goblin , 380 Carbon
                Oxy 4 - 360
                Oxy 4 - 325
                Oxy 3 - 250 , 3s
                Oxy 3 - 250 , 4s
                Oxy 3 - 280 , 3s
                Oxy 2 - 190
                Oxy 2 - 210
                XK K110. X 4 (best micro I’ve ever owned)
                Spektrum DX9
                Revolectrix PL6 & PL8

                Comment


                • #9
                  Having a Bailout setup in your flight controller is not necessarily going to save the heli, imo best to work out a bailout with each new manoeuvre your working on.
                  Today's outlook is fine for flying.
                  • Spektrum DX18 gen2, Phoenix Sims, Align MR25XP.
                  • Blade Nano, mCP X, 130x, Blade 180, Mini T 450se
                  • Trex 250dfc Gpro, Trex 500EFL Gpro.
                  • Trex 600E Gpro DFC, Trex 600NSP now Gpro, DFC, Redline 56
                  • Flickr Through My Pictures.
                  • A helicopter is an aircraft that is lifted and propelled by one or more horizontal rotors because Wikipedia said so.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Thanks Guys for your valuable input.
                    My concern with having the rescue feature (apologies I did call it bailout..i knew what I meant ..lol) is getting dependant on it, I barely have time to pull hold in if im going to crash! just too busy trying to save it!

                    That being said I have advised him to go with a system that has got rescue purely and simply because I feel that it is a vital tool whilst learning (we're all still learning!) and will bring him on quicker, certainly with the max angle feature/auto level engaged.

                    From A conversation ive had this morning with my mate (ErnieT5) on here - although yet to post he's going with the MSH Brain.

                    Thank you all again, was invaluable.

                    Rich
                    Heli's: Align 700X, TSA Infusion 700e Platinum, Align 600e Dominator, Align 600n pro DFC, Align 450 Pro DFC Stretched
                    Fixed Wing: SEBART Suhkoi 50e
                    Gear: Futaba 14SG

                    Newton Abbot Heli Club: http://www.naheliclub.org.uk/

                    Zeal Blades UK Flight Team www.zealblades.com

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Rich_H View Post
                      Thanks Guys for your valuable input.
                      My concern with having the rescue feature (apologies I did call it bailout..i knew what I meant ..lol) is getting dependant on it
                      FWIW I've always had rescue on my FBLs and am not dependent on it. I can self-rescue 99% of the time because I chose to learn that way. But rescue covers the other 1% of mistakes I make and more importantly gives me confidence to try new things knowing that I do have a safety net. I do practice using rescue both on the sim and in real life to get the muscle memory. It's no different to hitting TH in that respect, except without the cost! No crashes this year at all so far and only hit rescue for real once when I lost the plot while a bit too close to the ground for comfort. It was nice to see it snap level inverted and climb out.

                      MSH Brain sounds like a good choice for rescue, but not sure how well it works as a self-level trainer. I thought I'd read mixed reports of it in that mode?
                      SAB Goblin 380 KSE - latest love thang
                      Lynx OXY 3 - my mini flagship!
                      Blade 180 CFX - field beater for new moves
                      Blade Red Bull BO-105 CB 130 X - scale fun flying at the field when the tail isn't broken, which is not often.
                      Blade mCPX - sold

                      Blade Nano QX - house fly of choice
                      Blade mCX2 - retired but will be back when the kids get a bit bigger

                      Spektrum DX8 - for everything
                      ne
                      Xt sim - the sim I started out with
                      Heli-X sim - my new favourite sim!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        +1.

                        Self level is virtually impossible to use for learning unless you can adjust it.
                        Movement is very limited.
                        Heli's: Trex 700 - os gt15hz : Goblin 380 & MSH Brain - Trex 450 Ikon : Blade 550x & 180cfx
                        FPV: Sky Cruise 2400 - Cyclops Tornado - 700tvl cam
                        SkyWalker - Cyclops Tornado - 700tvl cam
                        DJI F550 - Naza v2 - iOsd - BT module - 700tvl cam
                        Mini Talon - MFD - 700tvl cam

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I think Pete has hit the nail on the head it's down to the way you learn. Most have learned to use hold so should be able to make the switch but you normally hit hold when you're in the shit and it's going in anyway. Me, I'm still trying to wrestle it from the grips of the ground demon before I think about hitting hold. If you start with bailout I do think it's a very different method than hold, at least it's used in the most at a very different time. I'd never get used to it due to the above although I'll give it a go with BeastX on a 450 and see how I get on.
                          Humble owner of 7 Eddie Gold Stars and Ex - member of Mk Heli Club
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I would say that rescue is far from needed for a beginner. The different levels of SAFE mode that you have on Blade micro BNF helis is alright for learning, but rescue on a collective pitch is a different kettle of fish!

                            I think the best FBL for a beginner is one that is (a) easy to understand and/or (b) is used both others in your club/area who can help you out when stuck.

                            I always thought the AR7200BX was a good FBL as it is easy to setup and doesn't need a PC / VBC / Datapod etc.
                            Tom
                            sigpic Synergy E7SE - Kontronic Helijive 120+ ESC, vBar Neo
                            SAB Goblin 630 Competition
                            - Castle Edge 120HV, vBar Neo
                            Blade 700X - Castle Edge 160HV ESC, Mini vBar
                            Logo 550SXv2 - Castle 130LV ESC, vBar Neo
                            .... and a Gaui X3
                            Spektrum DX8 ; Mikado VBC ; RealFlight 7 & neXt sims
                            ... and two EGS'



                            Comment


                            • #15
                              If you want any help give me a shout. It's a tight for on the pro but will for.
                              Oxy4+, tgy servos, hw60a, spirit fbl on 6s 🤓


                              sigpic - Team pilot

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X