Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

V bar log help please

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • V bar log help please

    Hi All, I would very much appreciate some help to understand my V bar log, following an unknown problem, causing logo to "fall out of the sky".
    As my sig says, I am running kontronik 100+LV, straight into the vbar, no life pack or similar. This might have been my first mistake .
    I was just doing a bit of sport flying ( my current level I'm afraid), the tail had twitched once or twice on other packs, but that was it! I had just had the 1 minute timer warning, so I spun it round, stopped it and started coming back to where we were standing, when it seemed to lose all power and dropped like a stone. My first thought was battery had been run too long( I normally use 5000mAh, this was a 3300mAh, set to 3 minutes), but it had 42% left when I checked it.

    I have just rebuilt it and don't really want to go flying again, as I don't know what happened first time round. My understanding of the log is that it seems to have lost signal, I'm running 2 spektrum sats. Or does the vbar have a residual power capacitor or summink allowing it to record for a short time after total power loss???
    Please excuse my ignorance on this matter, but I am hoping to be made a bit wiser following your replies.
    I did have to chuckle when I read the last extreme vibration level warning, that's probably when it hit the ground hahaha

    Here is the log, which I'm guessing is every flight it's ever had, I've only flown about 20 flights since I have had it!!
    Not sure if it is relevant, but the previous owner had a similar incident, where it dropped for no reason, but told me he had had the vbar checked and came back with a clean bill of health?? Or did it??



    log.pdf
    Last edited by pug907; 03-05-2013, 09:39 PM.
    Andy
    Logo 600 SX
    TT E700
    Synergy 516
    Vcontrol



    sigpic

  • #2
    V bar log help please

    When you reached the crash did you notice if the power was disconnected or the sats were flashing ?
    sigpic


    Rave ENV Nitro
    New Logo 550
    Synergy N5c
    TSA 700E night flier
    I use VBar control because it's feckin awesome I use NEO rescue when I remember to
    5 x EGS thingys and a Platinum star doo dah

    Comment


    • #3
      Hi Don, I didn't notice the sats flashing I'm afraid, but that's not to say they weren't. I was so stuck on it being the battery out of juice, I kind of ignored all else. A few seconds after it hit the deck, the servos started buzzing, a sound we hadn't noticed straight after it pranged, but you know what it's like when your heli has just gone in...... stunned silence, followed by "this is going to cost a bomb", then reality kicks in again.

      cheers
      Andy
      Logo 600 SX
      TT E700
      Synergy 516
      Vcontrol



      sigpic

      Comment


      • #4
        I would say, fix it all back up, and do some testing on the bench etc, no main or tails on. And also try the vibe anilizer also. Then recheck your logs.
        Santander Factory Team

        Proud wearer of 5 x EGS

        Comment


        • #5
          V bar log help please

          To a layman it certainly looks like you have antenna issues and total loss of signal for 7 seconds.hopefully someone more experienced can shed some light
          sigpic


          Rave ENV Nitro
          New Logo 550
          Synergy N5c
          TSA 700E night flier
          I use VBar control because it's feckin awesome I use NEO rescue when I remember to
          5 x EGS thingys and a Platinum star doo dah

          Comment


          • #6
            I have a log here that is very similar missed inputs then swap antenna....my 600 nitro just fell out of the sky...the tail went into a slow piro engine cut and no inputs...just fell too the ground I do think mine went into failsafe...and my rx battery was good....mybe its solar flairs who knows.....
            Last edited by jwatts007; 03-05-2013, 10:30 PM.
            Heli central...Basildon RC helis...strictly helis only...




            Comment


            • #7
              I should have said that it has heat shrink on the antennae. I have taken it off now, as I remember someone at our club having had 2 brownouts shortly after covering his antennae with heat shrink. Coincidence maybe??, but it might make me feel safer, if nothing else!!
              Andy
              Logo 600 SX
              TT E700
              Synergy 516
              Vcontrol



              sigpic

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by jwatts007 View Post
                I have a log here that is very similar missed inputs then swap antenna....my 600 nitro just fell out of the sky...the tail went into a slow piro engine cut and no inputs...just fell too the ground I do think mine went into failsafe...and my rx battery was good....mybe its solar flairs who knows.....
                It was a very weird day, we totalled a trex 250, stripped the 450 gears, pranged the 500, after tail fin holder broke, totalled my logo, Luke's 700 and Steve's 800.
                Oddly, the 250,450,500 and logo were all along a similar line when they went wrong??? Spooky huh?? maybe higher forces than sun spots at work here??
                Andy
                Logo 600 SX
                TT E700
                Synergy 516
                Vcontrol



                sigpic

                Comment


                • #9
                  well I get swap antenna on log s as well but is that how spectrum works ,if one antenna loses then the other takes over , have to say I have heat shrink on my sats ,never had a problem , but ill remove it for a day see what the logs say, u say tail twitched could it be static ?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by pug907 View Post
                    It was a very weird day, we totalled a trex 250, stripped the 450 gears, pranged the 500, after tail fin holder broke, totalled my logo, Luke's 700 and Steve's 800.
                    Oddly, the 250,450,500 and logo were all along a similar line when they went wrong??? Spooky huh?? maybe higher forces than sun spots at work here??
                    I do not know how too put the pdf on here...but its the same 4 errors then a swap antenna all through the log...if it was glitching it would not of been in such an order...and mine is a nitro powered model as well it still cut out...I think due too the failsafe after it lost signal...solar flairs is all I can think of....
                    Heli central...Basildon RC helis...strictly helis only...




                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by jimheli View Post
                      well I get swap antenna on log s as well but is that how spectrum works ,if one antenna loses then the other takes over , have to say I have heat shrink on my sats ,never had a problem , but ill remove it for a day see what the logs say, u say tail twitched could it be static ?
                      I have all the earthing straps on the heli, so doubt, nay hope it's not that.
                      Andy
                      Logo 600 SX
                      TT E700
                      Synergy 516
                      Vcontrol



                      sigpic

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by jwatts007 View Post
                        I do not know how too put the pdf on here...but its the same 4 errors then a swap antenna all through the log...if it was glitching it would not of been in such an order...and mine is a nitro powered model as well it still cut out...I think due too the failsafe after it lost signal...solar flairs is all I can think of....
                        According to the blurb next to error message, if sats are used all channels are blamed for any "incident" vbar sees?? I just hope it was a simple brown out, I can do without throwing good money after bad, chasing a problem that may not be there
                        Andy
                        Logo 600 SX
                        TT E700
                        Synergy 516
                        Vcontrol



                        sigpic

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Did you post on the Vbar site.

                          VBar Forum | VStabi

                          That is certainly a very vibe free log file. I have tried everything and still get plenty of raised vibrations.

                          Have you done a range check?




                          Goblin 700, Vbar Silverline, Savox SC-1267MG / SB-2272MG.Scorpion opto 130. Align 750mx /450kv
                          Trex 500 EFL Pro, DFC, Vbar 5.3 Full Pro.
                          CopterX 250 SE FBL, With Align upgrades and 3GX
                          JR XG 7
                          Mini CP, Heading for retirement.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by helimadness View Post
                            Did you post on the Vbar site.

                            VBar Forum | VStabi

                            That is certainly a very vibe free log file. I have tried everything and still get plenty of raised vibrations.

                            Have you done a range check?
                            I didn't know about the Vbar forum Tbh, thanks, I'll give it a try. I hadn't range checked it recently (hope I'm not going to be shot down for saying that ), but when it came down, it was only 50-60feet away, yet we had been flying it way further than that earlier, with no issues.
                            I'm glad to see you think it's pretty vibe free, as my mate had been 3D ing it 2 flights before. Not mad 3D, but a LOT harder than my usual pottering haha. A few hard stops, into rainbows etc, which looks pretty demanding on the heli.

                            My main concern, I guess, was to try to rule out a total power loss from the ESC, or battery connections (EC 5's) etc. I can live with the odd brown out, if that was the case, but don't want another prang if it's something fixable.
                            Cheers,
                            Andy
                            Logo 600 SX
                            TT E700
                            Synergy 516
                            Vcontrol



                            sigpic

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Have to confess, I'm no log expert, but just reading through it, it looks to me like ...

                              Between time 0:00 and 4:05 there are no issues. Occasional sat switches, but that's normal as far as I know.

                              At 4:12 it loses all input and attempts to fix by switching sats again.
                              At 4:13 on the other sat, it still sees no input.
                              At 4:14 to 4:16 it continuously switches sat trying to find input, but gets none.
                              At 4:19 it registers extreme vibration. I would guess this is the heli hitting terra firma!

                              In short, it was fine until 4:12 where it suffered complete loss of signal from both sats simultaneously.

                              So, to me it doesn't look like a sat issue since I think it's unlikely that both would fail simultaneously. So, the obvious common component is the transmitter - was that fully charged? (as others have said - range check!)

                              Unfortunately, the other common component is the vbar itself, or its integration components with sat rx's.

                              Another observation is that it happened at 4 mins into the flight. So whilst the LIPO still had 42% charge - it's possible I imagine that the volts may have been dropping under load? Though I'd imagine the VBAR would record this if so (does the vbar record low voltage? - don't know, but I'd imagine so).

                              What about satellite positioning? Do you have them properly installed (ie. 90 deg to each other, clear of carbon etc.). Unlikely as a cause I think, but worth a thought.

                              As already mentioned - I would fix and bench-test without blades. If you could get hold of a separate RX unit (eg. AR6210), you could isolate the Spektrum components from the equation. Then, if the problem goes away, you know it's something with the vbar. If it sticks around, it's a Sat or Transmitter issue?

                              Just my 2p ...
                              Tom
                              sigpic Synergy E7SE - Kontronic Helijive 120+ ESC, vBar Neo
                              SAB Goblin 630 Competition
                              - Castle Edge 120HV, vBar Neo
                              Blade 700X - Castle Edge 160HV ESC, Mini vBar
                              Logo 550SXv2 - Castle 130LV ESC, vBar Neo
                              .... and a Gaui X3
                              Spektrum DX8 ; Mikado VBC ; RealFlight 7 & neXt sims
                              ... and two EGS'



                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X